Shelley-Belly’s Underground Returns: 

Five Magical Evenings This Summer

For a minute there, I thought I was going to be a food blogger.

That dream met a swift and spicy end when I got pregnant and bought an inn in the same year… then had the baby and moved to Vermont to run the inn in the same month. (Madness!)

I kept the blog around, thinking I’d eventually find my way back to it. But then life happened. My son grew some, the business did too, and the blogging world—well, let’s just say it moved on without me.

At the same time as I was inexpertly dipping my toe into the world of food blogging, I was dabbling in the world of underground dining in Miami. My little pop-up, Shelley-Belly’s Underground, was chaotic, magical, and bursting with energy. There was no sign on the door and no phone number to call—just a long waitlist and a seat at the table if you were lucky. I loved every minute of it, and I always thought I’d bring it back one day.

Well… one day has come.

This summer, The Nutmeg will revive Shelley-Belly’s Underground for just five Saturdays, from July 19 to August 15. We’ll be serving a two-course prix-fixe dinner designed to get you on your way in time for the 8pm concerts at the Marlboro Music Festival (only 8 miles down the road). 🎶

Not heading to the concert?
No problem—you’re still invited. Book our second seating at 7:30pm and linger over dinner without the rush.


🍽️ Details You Need:

  • $48 per person (plus tax + gratuity)
  • Advance booking is essential – [Book your seat on Eventbrite here]
  • Credit card required at booking
  • Beer, wine, and soft drinks available for purchase
  • Cancellations within 7 days or no-shows will be charged in full

We’re not offering a vegan menu at this time, but we’re happy to accommodate vegetarians with a little notice. If you have allergies or dietary restrictions, please reach out when booking—we’ll do our best!

👉 Room reservations should be booked separately on The Nutmeg’s website.
👉 Concert tickets can be purchased directly from Marlboro Music.


Come hungry. Leave happy. Go hear something beautiful.
Hope to see you at the table this summer. 🖤

Duck and cherry pithivier

IMG_8496

Shelley-belly’s Underground is very excited to be catering the wedding rehearsal of a couple that attended one of our very first underground dinners and we’ve spent the past few weeks playing with old recipes and inventing new ones to make their night extra special.

So this post is not going to be about their dinner, that menu has to stay secret for a another week or so, this post is about the dish that got the chop. It was my favorite of our discarded ideas – it was too gluteny for a dinner that [unexpectedly] has to be gluten-free.

A pithivier, really just a fancy word for “pie” (and also a town in France), is, traditionally, a sweet pastry filled with frangipane and fruit. I filled mine with braised duck and the last of the summer’s cherries and served them with charred carrots and a duck and cherry jus.

I won’t bore you with the recipe, let’s face it, we’re all mostly interested in pictures anyway, but if you’d like the recipe please email me and I’ll be happy to give it to you.

Once again, I got so involved in the making-of that I forgot to take photos so you’ll just have to take my word for it when I say that making the Pithiviers was time consuming and lots of fun.. if, like me, playing with pastry and filling is your idea of fun.

IMG_8497

 

IMG_8498

IMG_8492IMG_7788

Farro and foie

I’ve blogged this dish because I love it and really wanted to share it. However, I’ve now made it six or seven times and not once, seriously not once, have I remembered to take photos of it. So you’ll have to use your imaginations or have a look at Fatgirl Hedonist’s blog about her experience – there’s a photo there. I’ve no doubt I’ll be making it again soon though, so will post photos when I do.

One of my favourite food memories, one I revisit regularly, is of a wild boar and foie gras sausage at Bocca di Lupo in Soho, London.

I’m not going to set the scene, drag you with me through a recollection of slushy London streets on a rainy autumn afternoon. I’m not going to tell you I had no reservation at a restaurant that ritualistically cannot seat you without one. Build suspense about my teary conversation with the hostess and finally being given a seat at (gasp!) the best table in the house – the bar, a front row seat to watching the magic happen.

I’m not going to do any of that, I’m simply going to tell you about one perfect mouthful of food.

So it was the wild boar and foie gras sausage served on a little mountain of steaming hot farro. It was fine. Nice. Better than nice. Delicious even. But mostly it was just sausage and farro. And then one perfect forkful – the foie gras had melted. It leaked  and oozed and spilled out of the sausage and puddled onto the plate. My next, slightly disinterested mouthful (I was reading a pretty interesting book at the time) is the one I think about regularly. A small heap of nutty farro grains on the end of my fork, each one perfectly coated in the unctuous, rich, fatty foie gras. Simply the best mouthful of food ever.

I think about it often. I’ve even been back and tried to recreate that perfect moment. It’s good, always good, just never quite the same. But still, I think about it often.

And of course, I did actually try to recreate it myself. I don’t think I’ll ever manage an exact replica of that one perfect mouthful – too many stars would have to align to make it so, but this is what I did…

First I bought a tronchon of foie gras from Hudson Valley Foie Gras & Duck Products. I cut it into chunks, wrapped each one in cling film and popped them in the freezer (and promptly forgot about them). But then, when I remembered them, I did the following.

I cooked up some farro. Steaming hot, al dente, well seasoned. Then I used a microplane to grate a generous mound of foie gras into a chilled dish (if you try this, chill your dish in the freezer and immediately after grating the foie gras put the whole lot back into the freezer until you need it). When I was ready to serve I spooned the foie gras (again, generously) onto the farro and stood back and watched as the curls of foie gras unfurled and started to melt. Delicious. Almost perfect. But missing something.

I did it again. Exactly as I had done before but this time with a tablespoon of foie gras stirred through the farro before I plated it. Really, so close to perfect but still missing a little something. Balance. Texture. Sweetness.

So I did it again. Exactly as I had done before but this time with a tablespoon of foie gras stirred through it before I plated and with a teaspoon of crushed peanut brittle – salty, sweet, bitter peanut brittle – sprinkled on top.

It was perfect.

In the interest of full disclosure I should tell you that none of these ideas are exactly mine – I’ve already come clean about the farro/foie gras pairing being a Bocca di Lupo creation. The grated foie gras is something David Chang does at Momofuku Ko and his dish also features a brittle, though at Ko they use pine nut not peanut and I suspect it is somewhat less bitter than mine. I let the caramel go a little further than I normally would with a brittle because I thought the bitterness would add an additional flavour layer to the dish. I was very happy with the result. I think my guests were too.