Let me start by addressing the “that’s so 70s” accusation. Yes, it is. But in the 70s I was mostly eating pureed carrots and omelettes with ketchup smiley faces on them – my mom wasn’t whipping up a lot of consommés for my supper and serving it to me on elegant avocado-colored dinnerware. I missed the consommé dinner parties… so I’m bringing them back. I’m thinking of bringing back chicken Kiev and cocktail onions and little cubes of cheese on toothpicks as well. And building a sunken lounge with wall-to-wall brown shag carpeting. It’s going to be awesome.
So now that that’s out of the way, I’ll try keep this brief – though we all know I’m not very good at the follow-through on that sort of promise.
I wanted a beautiful, clear consommé with tiny jewels of olive oil floating on the top. I wanted the flavor to be bright and fresh, more “just-picked” tomato with a hint of garlic and herbs than cooked tomato. It only took a few tries and the final product took much less time to prepare than I thought it would.
Here’s how I did it…
For the consommé base
- 1kg (or a little more) of ripe tomatoes roughly chopped into 2cm cubes . The best tomatoes I could find on the day were yellow ones, but any color will do. Buy the best you can afford, make sure they’re ripe, even a little overripe is good (but just a little).
- 2 or 3 good sized fresh garlic cloves. Don’t use the manky old cloves that have been hanging out in the bottom of the veg rack for weeks. You want bright, fresh flavors and you won’t get those from old garlic cloves.
- 1 tablespoon smoked salt. I really like the combination of smoked salt and tomatoes but it’s not essential, regular sea salt or kosher salt will do just as well (not table salt).
- 1/2 teaspoon sugar.
- 2 sprigs of thyme.
- A couple of glugs of good extra virgin olive oil
For the raft
- 1 small handful fresh basil.
- 6 large or 8 medium egg whites – pasteurized liquid egg whites should work (though I’ve not tried them), if you weigh them out you’ll need about 220g.
Sprinkle the salt and sugar over the tomatoes and let them stand for a few minutes.
Finely chop (not crush) the garlic and put it and the olive into a large saucepan on a low heat, you’re not cooking the garlic, just softening it a little and infusing the olive oil – I would not usually advocate cooking with good extra virgin olive oil but in this case you are not going to let it get hot enough to degrade the quality or alter the flavor.
When the oil has warmed and is fragrant from the garlic add the thyme and the tomatoes, stir to coat and put back on a low heat. Add enough warm water to just cover the tomatoes and simmer until the tomatoes are soft enough to squish with the back of a spoon – about 20 minutes or so. Obviously cooking this for longer will give you a more intense tomato flavor, so just do what works for you.
When the tomatoes have softened, remove from the heat and allow to cool a little then pour the whole mixture into a sieve over a clean glass bowl and push down on the flesh to release as much liquid and pulp as possible, leaving behind skins, seeds and any pithy bits. Cover with cling film pressed right down onto the surface** of the tomato puree and refrigerate until completely chilled then make the raft.
Finely chop the basil. Beat the egg whites until frothy and stir in the basil. (You an add other herbs as well if you wish, just don’t be too generous with your herbs – the consommé very quickly picks up the herb flavors and they can overpower your dish. Less is more).
For this next step it is best to use a pot that’s deep rather than wide. Put the chilled tomato into the pot on a medium/low heat and, using a whisk, gently stir in the egg whites, stop stirring as soon as it starts to simmer. Keep the heat low, don’t let it boil. As the raft forms, try make a ladle-sized hole in the middle of it. This helps you see when the consommé is clear and makes it easier to remove the liquid later on.
Meat consommés can take an hour or more to clarify but this is much quicker and will probably take less than 15 minutes. As soon as it looks clear remove it from the heat and gently ladle the liquid into a sieve lined with kitchen paper. Again, cover with film and refrigerate until you’re ready to use it.
It’ll keep for about a week in the fridge but keeps very well in the freezer so is a good make-ahead.
At an Underground a couple of weeks ago I served this tomato consommé as a palate cleanser between a fish starter and a rich meat main. I garnished it with a few deep fried basil leaves. The menu board said simply “tomato soup” – I loved the surprise on my guests’ faces when I served the “soup”, and again when they experienced the burst of flavor from what essentially looked like a glass of slightly discolored water. And again when they crushed the crispy basil leaves between their tongue and the roof of their mouths.
And for Geoff… a perfectly clear Bloody Mary
So I was in the swing of making consommés and really getting the hang of it and decided a perfectly clear Bloody Mary was in order – you’ve got to try this.
- 1 kg tomatoes
- 1 tsp celery salt
- fresh chilli peppers, sliced or chopped, seeds removed (optional and to your own taste – you can even substitute your favorite hot sauce)
- Worcestershire sauce (also optional and to your own taste)
For the raft
- 4 large or 6 medium egg whites – this cooks for far less time and needs fewer egg whites than a regular consommé
- 1/2 a stick of celery
- A few celery leaves if your celery bunch has any
I chose to make my clear tomato juice into an actual Bloody Mary mix but if you prefer to keep the tomato juice pure and add your seasoning later you can.
Chop up the tomatoes into chunks, sprinkle with celery salt and leave to stand for a few minutes.
As Bloody Marys are made from tomato juice rather than cooked tomato I just tossed the tomatoes, chilli peppers and Worcestershire sauce into my blender and blitzed the whole lot down to a puree.
Press the puree through a sieve into a clean glass bowl to remove seeds and skins. As the mixture is already cool you can just pop it straight into a pot, again, choose a pot that is deep rather than wide.
Finely chop the celery and celery leaves, beat the egg whites until frothy and stir in the celery. Gently stir in the egg whites into the tomato. Keep the heat low, don’t let it boil and stop stirring as soon as it starts to simmer. As the raft forms, try make a ladle-sized hole in the middle of it. This helps you see when the consommé is clear and makes it easier to remove the liquid later on.
Clarifying this uncooked tomato mixture happened much quicker than it did with a cooked tomato mixture – less than four minutes (if I was a bit sciency I might know why – maybe it has something to do with the level of acid in the uncooked tomato? If you know or if you have a theory, I’d love to hear it), so don’t leave the pot alone, just watch it until it’s ready to come off the heat.
When it’s ready, ladle the juice into a sieve lined with kitchen paper and refrigerate in a jug or bottle until you’re ready for a bloody mary – will keep in the fridge for about a week or in the freezer for a few months.
- 50 ml of your favorite good vodka
- 200 ml clarified tomato juice
- Freshly cracked black pepper
Garnish – I’m told (by the afore mentioned Geoff) that in the South, the garnish of choice for a Bloody Mary is pickled okra. Now I know that, despite its very southern location, Miami doesn’t really consider itself part of the South but we decided to give it a go. And goodness me, it was delicious. There’s no going back to celery garnish now. We picked up a jar of pickled okra from a farm stall in Alabama a few months ago but I’m sure you can get it at the supermarket (or pickle your own?).
I also tried one with a few hot pickled peppers…
The down side… 1 kg of tomatoes only yielded enough juice for four Bloody Marys. I still think it’s worth doing, buy maybe more so if it’s at the height of summer, you’re growing your own and you happen to have a glut of tomatoes.
** If there is any fat or oil in your soup (or anything really, a braise, a stew, a sauce, a stock) it will rise to the top as the dish cools – pressing the cling film onto the surface will help remove any excess fat.
I’d love your feedback if you give either of these recipes a try, and I’d also like to hear about your other consommé efforts. Thanks for stopping by.